MCP: When prions are personal
Almost everyone produces the prion protein known as PrP, which is found in the brain and cerebrospinal fluid. Like most proteins, PrP folds into a characteristic structure when it is produced. But sometimes that structure can change. When one copy of PrP adopts a misfolded shape, other prion proteins it comes into contact with tend to adopt the same shape. The misfolded proteins spread like an infection, and they tend to clump together, damaging the brain.The prion protein forms fibrils like the ones shown here.NIAID
A research team with an especially personal stake in prion diseases has developed a new measurement that may be useful in testing the treatments they aim to pioneer.
For husband and wife team Sonia Vallabh and Eric Vallabh Minikel, prions became personal when Vallabh’s mother died in her early fifties of a mysterious, rapidly advancing neurodegenerative disease. An autopsy showed that the culprit was a genetic prion disorder, a variant in PrP that makes the protein more likely to adopt a misfolded prion conformation. A test revealed that Vallabh, who is now in her thirties, had the gene too.
“She has a very high probability of developing the same disease by midlife,” Minikel said. “And once it strikes, it’s rapidly fatal.”
After that genetic test, Vallabh and Minikel changed their lives. They started taking night classes in biology and took entry-level jobs in laboratories. They founded the Prion Alliance, a nonprofit dedicated to finding a cure. With support from leaders at Boston’s Broad Institute, they enrolled in Harvard Medical School, and last spring they defended their Ph.D. theses, which focused on the mechanisms of prion disease, in back-to-back seminars. Now they’re looking ahead toward testing treatments.
Researchers hope that if they can find a way to reduce the amount of prion protein in a person predisposed to prion disease, they can reduce the chances that person will develop the disease, or they might be able to delay the onset of symptoms.
But how will researchers know if a potential treatment is working?
“The first and most basic thing you do in a clinical trial that’s the first in humans is you try to find a dose that is potent and tolerated,” Minikel said.
To measure a drug candidate’s potency, researchers usually test for how much it affects its target. In this case, that would mean looking for a drop in PrP after treatment. However, in the normal course of this disease, the amount of detectable PrP drops dramatically after a person begins to show symptoms.
“It’s very nonintuitive … trying to lower a thing that already goes down at the onset of disease,” Minikel said.
If disease progression and an effective drug candidate had the same effect on circulating PrP level, researchers would need to test the drug long before the disease began. And they weren’t even sure if the PrP drop in the test results reflected reality. The most common test relies on an interaction between PrP and an antibody that recognizes its shape. As PrP refolds, the researchers wondered, could it become invisible to the antibody while still present in the cerebrospinal fluid?
As part of his thesis work, Minikel helped develop a new test to resolve this question. With colleagues at the Broad Institute who specialize in proteomics, he came up with a way to detect PrP that doesn’t depend on the protein’s shape. Instead, using a mass spectrometry technique called multiple reaction monitoring, the approach breaks the protein into bits and measures its constituent parts. That means that even if the protein has changed shape, the assay can still detect it. The work recently was published in the journal Molecular & Cellular Proteomics.
Using this new assay to measure biobanked samples from patients, Minikel and his colleagues confirmed that PrP in the cerebrospinal fluid drops in the course of prion disease. Where the PrP goes is still an open question. But with greater confidence that it is indeed dropping when disease starts, the team has a roadmap for the best possible clinical tests for the drugs that they’re starting to develop: They need to test potential drugs in people at risk of prion diseases who have not yet shown symptoms.
Working with a commercial partner, Vallabh and Minikel have started testing drug candidates in mice using antisense oligonucleotides, a technology that should suppress the production of prion protein. They hope it will reduce the damage done by misfolded PrP. The early trials give Minikel hope, he said: Mice with genetic prion disorders, if treated before they show symptoms, survive longer without disease.
Even if this drug candidate doesn’t prove effective, Minikel looks with pride at the groundwork they’ve laid.
“We’ve made tremendous progress in making this a what people in the industry would call a ‘developable disease,’” he said. “And I think that’s a really promising step forward no matter what happens with the antisense oligonucleotides.”
Join the ASBMB Today mailing list
Sign up to get updates on articles, interviews and events.
University of Illinois at Chicago researchers and colleagues report a new mechanism for detecting foreign material during early immune responses.
Drugs like aspirin dampen inflammation by inhibiting certain enzymes but can have nasty gastrointestinal side effects, so enzymologists are investigating the structure of the enzymes’ active sites in hopes of designing more selective inhibitors.
Norovirus is very infectious, but not everyone is equally vulnerable. Whether you get sick or not may depend on your blood type.