Blotter

FIRM Act would require some foreign scientists to register as foreign agents

Sarina Neote
March 12, 2020

In late January, U.S. Rep. Seth Moulton, D-Mass., introduced the Foreign Influence Registration Modernization Act, or the FIRM Act, to the U.S. House of Representatives. This bill would require people in pursuit of academic or scholarly work who represent foreign governments that engage in human rights abuses to register as foreign agents. If enacted, this legislation would affect some foreign scientists collaborating with U.S. scientists on federally funded research.

With this bill, Moulton seeks to amend the Foreign Agents Registration Act of 1938, called FARA for short. That act was originally intended, as Moulton put it in an article in Time magazine, to “counter the rise of fascism in America as foreign operatives were spreading disinformation and propaganda.” FARA requires individuals who represent the interests of foreign powers in a political capacity or quasi political capacity to disclose their relationships with the foreign governments and register as foreign agents.

Moulton’s bill, meanwhile, is intended to modernize the disclosure requirements for foreign agents by digitizing the process; it also would narrow the definition of a foreign agent to an individual representing a foreign government, instead of “foreign powers.” In doing so, this act changes the exemption for scientists; under FARA, individuals in scholarly or scientific pursuit representing a foreign government do not have to register as foreign agents. But under the FIRM Act, any scientist representing a foreign government or receiving financial contributions directly from a foreign government that has committed human rights abuses would have to register as a foreign agent.

This would include any scientists who participate in foreign talent-recruitment programs, such as China’s Ten Thousand Program, which has been at the center of violations of research integrity. Moulton has insisted that “China has an all-out government effort to infiltrate our national security and education institutions.”

In recent years, several foreign researchers have failed to disclose funding they receive from China or have violated the confidentiality of peer review at the National Institutes of Health. The NIH has investigated at least 180 scientists at more than 65 institutions since 2018 for “violating policies requiring grantees to report their foreign ties.

The NIH has been working closely with the FBI to conduct these investigations and has referred several cases of alleged foreign influence in federally funded research to the FBI.

The FBI also has urged universities to review research conducted by Chinese scientists that could have defense applications. Since 2018, federal investigators have visited 10 institutions with a list of Chinese research institutions and/or companies for the university to monitor for research violations. The FBI also has been offering briefings to universities about foreign influences on scientific research conducted in the U.S.

The FIRM Act has been referred to the House judiciary committee. A month after the bill was introduced, U.S. Rep. Banks, R-Ind., co-sponsored the bill, indicating that the bill is gaining some traction. The judiciary committee will decide to whether to revise the bill or recommend a vote by the full House.

The ASBMB will continue track and report on the progress of this bill and other developments regarding foreign influence in U.S. scientific research.

Sarina Neote

Sarina Neote is ASBMB's science policy manager.

Join the ASBMB Today mailing list

Sign up to get updates on articles, interviews and events.

Latest in Policy

Policy highlights or most popular articles

U.S. seeks to kick out and ban foreign students
Blotter

U.S. seeks to kick out and ban foreign students

July 08, 2020

Harvard and MIT sue government to stop rule change targeting F-1 and M-1 visa holders at or heading to institutions offering only online courses this fall because of COVID-19.

NIH struggles to address sexual harassment by grantees
Blotter

NIH struggles to address sexual harassment by grantees

July 01, 2020

While the agency has made progress with intramural cases, it has been less successful with extramural ones.

What the Supreme Court's DACA ruling means for undocumented students and the colleges and universities they attend
News

What the Supreme Court's DACA ruling means for undocumented students and the colleges and universities they attend

June 27, 2020

At least for now, hundreds of thousands of students can stay in school without facing new hardships.

When leaders choose self-interest over science, the consequences are deadly
Editorial

When leaders choose self-interest over science, the consequences are deadly

June 26, 2020

As a result of the Trump administration’s actions and inaction, Ben Corb writes, the U.S. was late to adopt a testing protocol to help track and slow the spread of COVID-19.

NIH continues to investigate scientists’ foreign ties
Blotter

NIH continues to investigate scientists’ foreign ties

June 26, 2020

The agency has investigated 189 scientists suspected of violating NIH policies and has found a majority of them guilty of failing to disclose foreign affiliations.

Bill would reform NSF and plant innovation hubs nationwide
Blotter

Bill would reform NSF and plant innovation hubs nationwide

June 17, 2020

The Endless Frontier Act would rename, add a directorate to and pump up to $100 billion in new funding into the agency. It also would fix the uneven distribution of jobs and capital concentrated now in just a few cities.