Essay

What is better for your career than a publication? A preprint.

Ken Hallenbeck
Sept. 22, 2022

Publication in a peer-reviewed journal is the goal of almost all academic research, because authorship is accepted by the scientific community as a career accomplishment. This is a challenge for early-career researchers, or ECRs, because the modern peer-review process can take months to years from initial submission to final acceptance.

ECRs can be stuck trying to leverage a completed project into a career advance without final publication acceptance. Often, ECRs record not-yet-published manuscripts as “in preparation,” “under review” or “accepted,” but that doesn’t help a hiring committee examine the work itself. One way to circumvent this problem is by preprinting.

Preprinting is the practice of uploading a completed manuscript to a public server. Currently, over 50 preprint servers cover a wide range of disciplines, and conversations about the practice have reached the mainstream media. The overall growth in preprinted manuscripts is accelerating.

So should you join the preprinting revolution?

Preprinting pros and cons

Depositing a paper outside of an academic journal allows an author to start promoting the work immediately. A first or co-first author on the job market can link directly to the manuscript in their CV and during interviews. In addition, studies show preprints that go on to publication in a peer-reviewed journal have increased readership and are cited more often. Preprinting not only speeds up the initial sharing process but also adds value in the long term.

One reason for this increased readership is that preprints have no access barriers. Preprint servers are free to use and free to access, expanding the readership reach of an article and enabling open science. Anyone can read, comment on and cite preprints, and that gives preprinted work a wider audience.

Given the accessibility of preprints, authors often are concerned about the risk of scooping — a competing research group will see the preprint and rush to publish their results in a journal before the preprint authors have an opportunity to do so themselves. However, I have seen no evidence that data published in preprints is scooped more often than data withheld until journal publication.

In fact, the opposite is true. Researchers have used their preprints to initiate collaborations with other groups in the field or to coordinate simultaneous publication of their work, thereby avoiding concerns about priority claims. As a recent example, Josh Hardy, an adjunct research associate at Monash University, saw a preprint from another group and got in touch with the preprint authors. The two groups coordinated the journal publication of their respective papers, which ended up appearing in the same journal.

The number of papers printed on preprint servers has jumped in the last two years.
KEN HALLENBECK
The number of papers printed on preprint servers has jumped in the last two years.

Preprinting practicalities

All authors must be on board to preprint a manuscript, and the conversations should happen early in the drafting process so there is time to address concerns. There are a variety of resources that may assuage their concerns, such as the ASAPBio FAQ.

There are a few important things to consider once you have the go-ahead to preprint.

  1. Journal: If you plan to submit the manuscript to a journal, familiarize yourself with the journal’s editorial policies about preprints. Some journals specify the preprint servers that they accept for preprint deposition.
  2. License: It is also important to think about the license you will apply to the preprint. There are several options — from no license (meaning you do not give default permission to reuse the work) to a range of Creative Commons licenses that designate the type of uses allowed.
  3. Format: In general, preprint servers are format agnostic, meaning they accept a single file of your manuscript in any format (for example, a single PDF file in the formatting style of the journal of your choice!) and then authorship information. However, some journals work with preprint servers to allow for direct submission of your manuscript to a journal after posting to the preprint server. You may only need to click one button for preprint and journal submission!

Many researchers are still wary of preprinting; perhaps you or a co-author have unaddressed concerns. A more detailed guide on preprints, their history and the current status of adoption is available as a preprint (of course!): A Guide to Preprinting for Early Career Researchers.” I also suggest you keep an eye on the latest preprints coming out in your research field. New results are preprinted every day, and you might just find your next collaborator!

Disclosure: The author participated in the ASAPbio Fellows program in 2021.

Enjoy reading ASBMB Today?

Become a member to receive the print edition monthly and the digital edition weekly.

Learn more
Ken Hallenbeck

Ken Hallenbeck earned a Ph.D. in pharmaceutical sciences from the University of California, San Francisco, and now is an early drug-discovery researcher. He serves on the board of directors of ReImagine Science and is the life sciences lead at TerraPrime.

Featured jobs

from the ASBMB career center

Get the latest from ASBMB Today

Enter your email address, and we’ll send you a weekly email with recent articles, interviews and more.

Latest in Opinions

Opinions highlights or most popular articles

The silent toll of unpromotable work
Professional Development

The silent toll of unpromotable work

June 9, 2023

Extra commitments are everywhere in academia. Many take time and effort but do not advance a faculty member’s career.

Listen, learn and support
Pride

Listen, learn and support

June 8, 2023

Four LGBTQIA+ scientists share their stories and reflect on progress and setbacks for inclusivity and support.

Science will suffer
Editor's Note

Science will suffer

June 1, 2023

We wondered if laws targeting LGBTQIA+ rights were affecting the career decisions of our members. It wasn’t easy to get answers.

As microbiome science forges ahead, will some be left behind?
Essay

As microbiome science forges ahead, will some be left behind?

May 27, 2023

The FDA’s approval of the first fecal microbiota treatment was a watershed moment — and also a wakeup call.

Cystic fibrosis: current understanding and prospects
Health Observance

Cystic fibrosis: current understanding and prospects

May 26, 2023

In observance of National Cystic Fibrosis Awareness Month, we talked with researcher Neil Bradbury.

Those who care and engage
Editor's Note

Those who care and engage

May 18, 2023

Being an ASBMB fellow isn’t just about hanging around together; it’s about engaging with others and moving together into the unknown.