Reimagining

Merging biochemical and analytical training

Clément Vinauger
By Clément Vinauger
July 8, 2021

Recent advances in molecular and biochemical methods such as mass spectrometry and high-throughput sequencing have accelerated the rate of scientific discovery and exponentially increased the volume of data that a single study can generate. The COVID-19 pandemic has stimulated researchers to integrate genome sequencing, automatized large-scale testing, rapid and efficient sharing of information, modeling, and computational studies to generate evidence-based solutions to global problems.

We also have been challenged to be more creative and flexible in our approach to the way we work and teach. For some scientists, this has meant increasing our reliance on computer networks and computational methods to compensate for limited access to the laboratory bench. In other words, the pandemic revealed that while it is critical for us to specialize and have depth of knowledge in some domains, it is also essential that we cultivate some breadth in our skill set.

A need for programming literacy

Question-driven research often requires the analysis of large volumes of heterogeneous data to generate accurate and comprehensive answers. Often, these data must be integrated into predictive models. For example, in my laboratory we integrate headspace volatiles analysis, transcriptomics and electrophysiological recordings to understand the chemical basis of mosquito–host interactions.

Integrated multidisciplinary research is not new and not limited to the fields of biochemistry and molecular biology. In both academia and industry, scientists at all levels need to be able to work at the bench and operate advanced scientific equipment as well as process, wrangle, integrate and analyze heterogeneous data. Our colleagues in neuroscience combine behavioral data with neural activity recordings, functional imaging studies, gene expression profiles, computational approaches and mathematical modeling. Ecologists integrate temporal population census data with climatic and geographic information to discern how organisms interact with their environment. As these multidisciplinary approaches spread, we need to train what data scientists refer to as “pi-shaped” researchers: investigators possessing a broad understanding of the sciences supported by a deep knowledge of their specific area of expertise and a foundation in data science. The presence of these π-shaped experts on problem-solving teams facilitates the process of data collection, visualization and interpretation by freeing these teams from communication gaps between topic expertise and data scientists.

Training π-shaped researchers

Figure1-445x363.jpg
Clément Vinauger
Steve Brunton, an associate professor of mechanical engineering at the University of Washington, provides a great definition of the π-shaped expert concept (illustrated here) in his online lecture “Introduction to Data Science” on YouTube.

Data science requires both computer literacy and familiarity with a programming language. While some students are curious about programming and learn how to code in Python or R on their own, others don’t have this exposure to data wrangling unless they are part of the roughly 54% of undergraduates (averaged across science, technology and engineering and mathematics disciplines) who participate in extracurricular research. At most colleges and universities, an extensive set of prerequisites is required for students to take advanced specialty classes in computer science and statistics — a challenge for biochemistry students who already have full schedules. In most bench and field science majors, computational training is optional and not part of a student’s core training. As a result, students have difficulty identifying how knowledge acquired in a statistics or computer science course can be applied to, for example, biochemistry.

In the biochemistry program at Virginia Tech, we developed a new course that exposes biochemistry majors to coding as they analyze large data sets relevant to the concepts and topics developed in class — for example, chemical communication. Students analyze large data sets collected in the instructor’s laboratory, ranging from electrophysiological recordings of olfactory neurons to gas chromatography–mass spectrometry analyses of the chemical composition of plant and human scent samples. In addition to programming in the open source language R, they work in teams to clean, wrangle, visualize and interpret data. They manipulate inferential statistics and use multivariate analysis and machine learning while answering biochemical and biological questions.

Copy, paste and tweak

If you were to type, “La mer, la vaste mer, console nos labeurs!” (from Charles Baudelaire’s poem “Moesta et Errabunda”) on your computer, would you have written one line of French poetry? Yes. Does this mean that you now are a poet or know how to communicate in French? Not exactly, right? The same applies to learning a programming language. Providing students with functional scripts does guarantee that they will produce an anticipated output. However, such assistance reduces the likelihood that they will be able to then tackle a slightly different problem. On the other hand, expecting non–data science students to become programming experts in a single semester is unrealistic.

Through a compromise approach, our students can acquire a working understanding of the programming relevant to their area of study. By working with data that students can relate to and that is directly relevant to the topic of the course, we offer them an opportunity to leverage lecture content and reading materials to identify the biochemical problem they are trying to solve. The central pedagogical objective is to foster students’ familiarity with key coding concepts and terms and to develop their ability to identify code syntax and structures that they can adapt to fit their needs and solve the biochemical problem.

Optimizing online

How does this look in the classroom? Before the pandemic, students worked side-by-side in small groups to brainstorm, code and debug while the instructor and teaching assistant moved between groups to provide individualized teaching. Physical distancing requirements have disrupted these activities, but online solutions exist that emulate these interactions.

During the spring semester of 2021, our class met in a virtual classroom on Gather.com, a video call platform. It is similar to Zoom or Teams, but each participant has an avatar that can move around the virtual classroom. Students worked collaboratively on their codes using platforms such as Google Drive and GitHub. With these tools, they were able to share their work with the instructors and get feedback and personalized help, and instructors were able more readily to comment, edit students’ code in real time and explain core coding concepts. We recorded lectures and group activities so students with added responsibilities (such as parenting), disabilities or scheduling conflicts can come back to the material later.

Clément Vinauger
Students work in a virtual classroom on the video call platform Gather, where every student has an avatar and group areas can be defined, allowing them to interact privately, share a screen or use virtual whiteboards. A video demo was made by student volunteers Kiley Stackpole, Michael Rauco, Xedrix Barbeyto, Lucie Lefbom and Jovia Ho and teaching assistant Brittany Hart.

Career benefits

Looking forward to the fall semester, now is a good time to reimagine a post-pandemic version of this new course in which analytical training can be even better integrated with core biochemistry education. Returning to in-person teaching should increase student engagement and mitigate some of the inequalities arising from their work-from-home environments. They still will be able to share and exchange data and work collaboratively online.

We have a unique opportunity to prepare undergraduates for professional scientific collaborations that are often long-distance, if not international. As we observed during the pandemic, online resources for collaborative work offer a remarkable medium to provide individualized feedback to students, bringing coursework one step closer to the one-on-one training students would get in a laboratory. By recording and sharing lectures and discussions via online platforms, we are able to reach students with varied learning styles and needs.

A foundation in data science tailored for biochemists and life scientists will give students an edge when applying to graduate or medical school or entering the job market. By exposing students to the use of online resources for collaborative work, we help them to hit the ground running when they move on to the next step of their training or the first step of their professional life.

Enjoy reading ASBMB Today?

Become a member to receive the print edition monthly and the digital edition weekly.

Learn more
Clément Vinauger
Clément Vinauger

Clément Vinauger is an assistant professor in the biochemistry department at Virginia Tech and a member of the Scientific Reports editorial board.

Get the latest from ASBMB Today

Enter your email address, and we’ll send you a weekly email with recent articles, interviews and more.

Latest in Opinions

Opinions highlights or most popular articles

Risk aversion is ruining science
Essay

Risk aversion is ruining science

May 21, 2022

To nurture scientific discovery, universities and grant institutions must do a better job of rewarding failure.

Trolling is taking a toll on science journalism
Science Communication

Trolling is taking a toll on science journalism

May 19, 2022

Science journalists say they face threats of online harassment — and that newsrooms are doing little to protect them.

Good fellows
Editor's Note

Good fellows

May 18, 2022

“To be a fellow, a member must be generous with time and talent — not just someone whose CV includes pages of individual BMB achievements.”

3 ways to make ‘belonging’ more than a buzzword in higher ed
Education

3 ways to make ‘belonging’ more than a buzzword in higher ed

May 18, 2022

“Studies have found that belonging is a key to college student success. … (It) is especially important for students of color who attend institutions that were not designed with them in mind.”

Making a bigger footprint
Essay

Making a bigger footprint

May 17, 2022

“I have resolved to assist the society in any way I can to build its international membership profile … I look forward to many of you joining me in this endeavor.”

James Bryant Howard (1942 – 2022)
Retrospective

James Bryant Howard (1942 – 2022)

May 16, 2022

He was an ASBMB member for more than 40 years, and he served on the Journal of Biological Chemistry editorial board from 1986 to 1991.