Blotter

Creative thinking necessary
to change culture

Benjamin Corb
June 21, 2019

Francis S. Collins, director of the National Institutes of Health, announced in a statement last week that he will no longer participate in panels that are not diverse.  Collins noted that women and members of underrepresented groups are “conspicuously missing” from high-level speaker slots and said that it is “time to end the tradition in science of all-male speaking panels, sometimes wryly referred to as ‘manels.’”

This move by Collins was clever. He used his platform as the leader of the world’s largest funder of biomedical research to make clear where he stands on a frustrating and antiquated problem.

Though his announcement was only a personal vow, it’s reasonable to assume that he has, in making said vow publicly, influenced how scientific conferences will operate going forward. No rule changes, months of working group deliberations or congressional prodding were needed. Just a blog post.

It’s time for NIH to do equally creative thinking when it comes to another longstanding problem in the life science community: sexual harassment.

In the same week as the no-manels announcement, the Advisory Committee to the Director heard from its working group assigned with changing the culture to prevent sexual harassment.

The working group presented tentative recommendations that seek to raise the seriousness with which professional misconduct is treated, improve reporting of violations, provide restorative justice for victims and rebalance the trainer–trainee power structure. Serious work went into identifying these areas of concern and developing the recommendations. However, the working group seems limited by its members’ imaginations.

The group frequently cited legal and statutory limitations that must be considered before it can make formal recommendations. These limitations also have been cited by NIH leadership as an explanation for its slow response to what many consider a crisis.

NIH should be looking for more creative ways to use its $40 billion-a-year budget as leverage over researchers and research institutions.

Formal rule changes and legislative fixes are long, frustrating and tedious ways to change culture, especially in institutions over which the NIH has no legal authority. 

Yet, if the NIH leadership allows itself to think outside of the box, they might find that there is a variety of ways to change the culture swiftly.

No more manels is a great start.  We look forward to seeing what’s next.

Update: Walter Koroshetz, director of the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke released a statement on June 20 stating that he would not participate in manels. John Lorsch, director of the National Institute of General Medical Sciences followed suit with his own statement on June 25, saying that neither he nor any members of NIGMS staff would attend conferences or meetings where “attention to inclusiveness is not evident.”

Benjamin Corb

Benjamin Corb is director of public affairs at ASBMB.

Join the ASBMB Today mailing list

Sign up to get updates on articles, interviews and events.

Latest in Policy

Policy highlights or most popular articles

Ex-Emory neuroscientist pleads guilty;  fired Cleveland Clinic geneticist arrested
Blotter

Ex-Emory neuroscientist pleads guilty; fired Cleveland Clinic geneticist arrested

May 20, 2020

Department of Justice continues to pursue scientists who fail to disclose ties to China’s Thousand Talents Program.

3 volunteering guidelines to heed during the coronavirus pandemic
News

3 volunteering guidelines to heed during the coronavirus pandemic

May 05, 2020

A volunteering expert offers guidance on how to help at a time when you might need to keep your helping hands to yourself.

Out of my comfort zone: How I use science to influence policy
Essay

Out of my comfort zone: How I use science to influence policy

April 30, 2020

When Amanda Koch realized that elected officials often do not make evidence-based decisions, she decided she wanted her scientific voice to be heard in politics.

Federal agencies struggle to address sexual harassment in STEM research
Blotter

Federal agencies struggle to address sexual harassment in STEM research

April 29, 2020

A Q&A with John Neumann of the General Accountability Office, whose team produced a report in March on federal funding agencies’ dealings with sexual harassment.

Air pollution could make people more vulnerable to COVID-19
News

Air pollution could make people more vulnerable to COVID-19

April 26, 2020

Air pollution hits harder in communities of color. Such exposures could lead to increased risks from the new coronavirus.

How is COVID-19 affecting NIH research?
Funding

How is COVID-19 affecting NIH research?

April 22, 2020

The ASBMB hosted a webinar with NIH officials to outline how they’re helping scientists navigate pandemic-related interruptions to their research.