Education

With college enrollment tumbling, new strategies are urgently needed

Four-year colleges must take notice — and reach out to nontraditional students
Joshua Wyner
By Joshua Wyner
June 10, 2022

U.S. college enrollments have declined by 3 million students over the past decade.  While the decrease has been concentrated in community colleges, it’s coming soon to many four-year institutions.

Demographers predict an “enrollment cliff” beginning in 2025, when the traditional college-age population will start shrinking for the foreseeable future. 

Unless they bring in more students, colleges will struggle financially, and some could shut their doors. Some are already doing so. The result: Fewer Americans will have the skills needed to strengthen our democracy, advance our knowledge-based economy and solve the challenges of our time — from climate change to life-threatening diseases to racial inequities. 

To reverse enrollment trends, colleges must do more than compete for the dwindling number of graduating high school seniors. They need new strategies to attract populations they have long undervalued and underserved: high-school students taking college courses, community-college transfers and working adults. 

Here are ways colleges can develop the talents of these three groups. 

High school students 

The number of high school students taking Advanced Placement courses has surged, increasing by 57% over the last decade, with even faster growth in the number of high schoolers taking college courses, mostly at community colleges. But too few of these dual-enrollment courses count toward a college degree; that’s a lost opportunity to make college more affordable for working-class students and families.

Colleges can bolster enrollments by better serving these dual-enrollment students. A great example: The Alamo Colleges District, a 90,000-student system in San Antonio, Texas, works with K-12 partners to advise thousands of diverse high schoolers to enroll in not just any college courses, but those aligned with valuable credentials.

Alamo has developed clear course sequences that advisers use to guide high school students to associate degree pathways that lead directly to good jobs or seamless transfers into bachelor’s degree programs at one of seven nearby universities. In this way, Alamo is translating growing interest in college-level work into what families care about most — setting students on a path to the bright future that comes with a high-quality degree. 

Community-college transfers

The vast majority of community college students want a bachelor’s degree, but only about one in every six accomplishes that goal within six years of community college entry. Those derailed most often are Black and Hispanic students, as well as students from low-income neighborhoods, who are more likely than others to begin higher education at a community college. 

To grow enrollments, universities and community colleges should stop competing against one another for students and compete together to substantially increase the likelihood that students will in fact obtain a bachelor’s degree. One excellent example: a partnership between Northern Virginia Community College (NOVA) and George Mason University. By enrolling new students at both institutions simultaneously, this large community college and top research university report that they are helping 3,000 students each year get on the path to a low-cost, high-quality bachelor’s degree — the most certain route to a well-paying job in northern Virginia.

Unlike most community college students, those enrolled in this program do not need to apply twice, or wonder if credits will transfer or sort through conflicting information from two financial aid offices.

Adults needing high-quality short-term training

Postsecondary education could help millions of adults move out of jobs that don’t pay family-sustaining wages. But they need salary increases much more quickly than the two years it takes to earn an associate degree, let alone the four years needed for a bachelor’s.

Unfortunately, research shows that many shorter-term credentials do not significantly increase salaries, and don’t lead to paths out of low-wage work. 

Colleges across the country can sustainably attract more students by ensuring that their short-term certificates actually lead to better-paying jobs with benefits. They can learn from Valencia College in Orlando, Florida, whose president reports that every year they deliver accelerated skills training to nearly 1,000 adults in construction, advanced manufacturing, information technology and other fields.In programs that last four to 22 weeks, students earn industry-recognized credentials that lead to substantially higher salaries as well as access to additional training to improve their job prospects. 

What lessons can educators learn from these examples? From 2010 to 2019, enrollments dropped 25% at community colleges nationwide, but held steady at NOVA and increased by 15% at Valencia and 20% at the Alamo Colleges District.

And while enrollments increased by just 20% at public four-year colleges in that decade, they rose nearly 50% at George Mason.

These stories demonstrate that new students will show up when they see campuses committed to delivering what they want and need. Enrollments will sustainably increase if college leaders develop new models that provide value to nontraditional populations.

By following these examples, other colleges and universities can reinvigorate themselves while creating opportunities for coming generations to bolster the country’s economy, democracy and capacity to solve pressing problems.  

This story was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. It was republished under a noncommercial Creative Common license.

Enjoy reading ASBMB Today?

Become a member to receive the print edition monthly and the digital edition weekly.

Learn more
Joshua Wyner
Joshua Wyner

Joshua Wyner, founder and executive director of the Aspen Institute College Excellence Program, is author of “What Excellent Community Colleges Do.”

Get the latest from ASBMB Today

Enter your email address, and we’ll send you a weekly email with recent articles, interviews and more.

Latest in Opinions

Opinions highlights or most popular articles

What is better for your career than a publication? A preprint.
Essay

What is better for your career than a publication? A preprint.

Sept. 22, 2022

“Depositing a paper outside of an academic journal allows an author to start promoting the work immediately,” Ken Hallenbeck writes.

Mentoring wins over training in science
Essay

Mentoring wins over training in science

Sept. 19, 2022

“Mentoring helps students to develop coping mechanisms to handle stress, uncertainty and unknowns that are an integral part of a scientific career,” Shantá D. Hinton writes.

What we’re asking for — on your behalf
News from the Hill

What we’re asking for — on your behalf

Sept. 14, 2022

The ASBMB’s recent advocacy activities focus on sustained funding for curiosity-driven science, safe and equitable work environments, and support for next-generation researchers.

Having an abortion during your Ph.D.
Essay

Having an abortion during your Ph.D.

Sept. 10, 2022

A graduate student reflects on her choice to end a pregnancy and on what the overturning of Roe v. Wade means for trainees in the United States.

‘How life began merits a preceding discussion of what life actually is’
Books

‘How life began merits a preceding discussion of what life actually is’

Sept. 8, 2022

A new book uses biochemistry and evolution to describe hypotheses of life’s origins and the last universal common ancestor, an anaerobic prokaryote.

Free digital tools for grad students

Free digital tools for grad students

Sept. 2, 2022

Our careers columnist curated a list of what she found to be the most helpful.