April 2011

Reading the scientific literature: a step-by-step process

An online-only reprint of an article from Enzymatic discussing the use of Journal of Biological Chemistry article figures as a teaching aid.


Cytotoxicity induced by IR or BLM in Ape1-deficient TK6 and HCT116 cells.

When teaching a senior level molecular biology lecture course, there is, in my case, an attempt to balance discussion of the core material with an introduction to the current research. The former provides much needed background but lacks perspective on the cutting edge research currently underway. Equally problematic, however, is a format that relies solely on primary research literature without ensuring that the students have a fundamental understanding of the core principles. In previous courses, I have tried to maintain this balance by covering core material in a relatively standard course structure (lecture, discussion, question/answer sessions and problem solving) while introducing the students to research papers throughout the semester. With respect to the core content, we discuss both the mechanisms of replication, transcription and translation as well as the experimental techniques used to study these mechanisms. Scientific literature is introduced by asking the students to read topical, up-to-date research articles that touch on the content under discussion. Students are also required to summarize a primary research article by the end of the semester that they themselves have chosen.

Although the students generally appreciate the mix of current research and general background, I have discovered that, while the students enjoy learning about the current research, many still have difficulty linking the core concepts to the research itself. Students may have difficulty interpreting the figures, identifying the key facts of the paper or explaining how the data supports the author’s conclusions. In order to assist in this transition, I have begun to incorporate article figures that relate to the lecture topic under discussion. Shown below is a description of this approach.

Student population: The molecular biology course is a required course for all molecular biology and biochemistry majors. Pre-requisites for the course include genetics, cell biology, microbiology and biochemistry. The course is generally taken at the end of a student’s junior year or beginning of his/her senior year. For molecular biology majors, this course is a pre-requisite for the molecular biology laboratory course.

Course topic: During this section of the course the discussion has focused on DNA repair.

Assignment: During class, students were asked to interpret figure 2 in the article by Fung et al., titled “Distinct Roles of Ape1 in the Repair of DNA Damage Induced by Ionizing Radiation or Bleomycin,” in the February 2011 issue of the Journal of Biological Chemistry (see figure). In this assignment, students were asked to first extract the key ideas of the figure and then progress to a more detailed and sophisticated interpretation of the data. Finally, the students were asked to then relate the experimental results to the content topic currently being discussed.

NEXT PAGE 1 | 2

First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Comment:


Comment on this item:
Rating:
Our comments are moderated. Maximum 1000 characters. We would appreciate it if you signed your name to your comment.


  


There aren't any comments on this item yet. Tell us what you think!

0 Comments

Page 1 of 1

found= true1302